Imposter Syndrome: The Pressure of Becoming a Steward

There is a particular kind of pressure that shows up when your work begins to matter in a new way.

You step into a bigger role.
The stakes rise.
More people depend on your judgment.
Your decisions carry more consequence than they used to.

And then, somewhere in that transition, a quiet question starts pressing from the inside:

Do I actually belong here?

It may not arrive dramatically. More often, it shows up as hesitation before speaking, over-preparation before a meeting, second-guessing decisions, or scanning the room for evidence that everyone else has figured out something you have not.

We call this imposter syndrome.

But despite how it feels, it is not always a sign that something is wrong with you. Often, it is the pressure of transformation. Your responsibilities have expanded faster than your identity has had time to metabolize.

You are not necessarily broken.

You may be becoming.

Research on the impostor phenomenon shows that it is common, with prevalence estimates ranging widely from 9% to 82%, depending on how it is measured and which population is studied. In other words, the feeling is not rare, and it is not proof that you are unqualified. (PubMed)

Why Imposter Syndrome Shows Up

Imposter syndrome often appears when a role asks more of you than your current self-concept can comfortably contain.

A bigger role does not just require new skills. It requires a new relationship with yourself.

You may need to release an older identity: the expert who always knew the answer, the high achiever who could win through effort alone, the agreeable teammate who avoided conflict, or the independent performer who never had to hold responsibility for a wider system.

That shift is exciting.

It is also hard.

Transformation is rarely clean. Adaptive work often involves real losses: loss of certainty, loss of old competence, loss of familiar identity. It generates disequilibrium before it generates maturity. (EdRedesign)

This is where imposter syndrome becomes a signal.

Not a verdict.

A signal.

The better question is not, “Am I a fraud?”

The better question is:

“What is this role asking me to become?”

Pressure Is Not the Problem. Uncontained Pressure Is.

Pressure can refine us, but only when it is contained.

Uncontained pressure becomes panic, shame, avoidance, control, people-pleasing, defensiveness, or burnout. Contained pressure becomes focus, humility, preparation, courage, and growth.

This is where leadership containment matters.

In ViDA’s article on Leadership Containment, the core idea is that as your scope increases, you become responsible not only for your own performance, but also for the emotional and psychological climate that allows others to perform. The article frames containment as the ability to steady yourself and the environment so people can function, adapt, and grow. (valuesdrivenachievement.com)

That is exactly what imposter syndrome tests.

This is not about pretending to be confident.

Working through imposter syndrome is about becoming more trustworthy and predictable under pressure.

The World Does Not Need More Leaders. It Needs More Stewards.

A lot of imposter syndrome gets worse because we interpret it through ego.

We ask:

How do I look?
Will they find me out?
Am I impressive enough?
Do they think I belong?

Those questions keep us trapped in shame.

A steward asks better questions:

What am I here to protect?
What am I here to grow?
Who depends on my maturity?
What value must lead right now?
What responsibility have I chosen to carry?

The world does not need more people performing leadership. It needs more people willing to steward something meaningful: a team, a family, a client relationship, a mission, a community, a craft, a company, a culture, a future.

A leader may chase status.

A steward carries responsibility.

A leader may want to be seen.

A steward wants the work to be served.

That shift matters because imposter syndrome becomes dangerous when it is interpreted through ego and shame. Our pain and discomfort becomes useful when it is interpreted through purpose, vision, values, and responsibility.

For a deeper values foundation, see the ViDA Values Framework, which defines values as lived states and traits that guide behaviour, decisions, and human interactions, not abstract words on a wall. (valuesdrivenachievement.com)

Do Not Suffer for the Sake of Suffering

There is nothing noble about pain without purpose.

We do not suffer because suffering is good.

We carry difficult things when they are attached to meaningful evolution.

There is a difference between pointless strain and chosen sacrifice. There is a difference between ego-driven endurance and values-driven maturity.

Pointless strain sounds like:

“I just have to prove I can handle this.”

Values-driven maturity sounds like:

“This is hard, and I choose to grow because the work matters.”

That distinction changes everything.

When pressure connects to purpose, it becomes energy.

When pressure connects only to ego, it becomes torment.

ViDA’s guide on Harnessing Stress as Performance Energy makes a similar point: stress can become a productive force when it is channelled properly, reframed, and managed before it turns into overwhelm. (valuesdrivenachievement.com)

So the goal is not to glorify discomfort.

The goal is to ask whether the discomfort is helping you mature into a role that serves the people and things you have chosen to steward.

Move From Pain and Pleasure to Purpose and Practice

Most people instinctively organize life around pain and pleasure.

Avoid pain. Chase pleasure. Protect the ego. Escape shame.

That system works for a while, but it is not strong enough for meaningful achievement. The moment the work becomes hard, the pain/pleasure system starts bargaining with you:

Avoid the meeting.
Delay the decision.
Say yes so they like you.
Say no so you cannot fail.
Stay small so you cannot be exposed.

Values-driven achievement requires a better system.

Instead of organizing around pain and pleasure, organize around:

Vision: What future am I working toward?
Purpose: Why does this matter?
Values: What qualities must I embody?
Character: Who must I become to carry this well?
Goals: What concrete progress will move the work forward?

ViDA’s article on setting your personal vision and purpose makes this distinction clear: vision provides the big-picture direction, purpose clarifies the reason behind it, and both are made real through values, principles, and action. (valuesdrivenachievement.com)

That is how you align the right parts of yourself with the roles you choose to play.

Not the scared part that needs applause.

Not the ashamed part that expects exposure.

Not the egoic part that wants dominance.

The values-aligned part.

The steward.

Use Imposter Syndrome to Build Autonomy, Connection, and Mastery

Self-Determination Theory gives us a useful lens here. It identifies three basic psychological needs that support growth and motivation: autonomy, competence, and relatedness. In practical terms, we can think of these as choice, mastery, and connection. (University of Rochester Medicine)

Imposter syndrome becomes more useful when we work with those three needs instead of against them.

Autonomy: Choose the role consciously.
Stop saying, “I have to prove myself.” Start saying, “I choose to steward this responsibility because it aligns with what matters to me.”

Connection: Do not isolate in shame.
Imposter syndrome grows in secrecy. Stewardship grows in relationship. Find mentors, peers, coaches, and trusted colleagues who can help you hold the pressure without becoming consumed by it.

Mastery: Turn fear into a development plan.
The useful question is not, “Why am I not already perfect?” The useful question is, “What skill, habit, conversation, or decision would make me more capable of serving this role?”

This is where motivation becomes more durable. ViDA’s article on motivation argues that consistency does not come from hype; it comes from alignment between work, beliefs, values, and process. (valuesdrivenachievement.com)

A Better Set of Questions

When imposter syndrome shows up, do not let it run the meeting.

Contain it.

Listen to it.

Then interrogate it with better questions:

What is this pressure asking me to learn?

Which value must lead right now: courage, care, clarity, humility, discipline, patience, or responsibility?

What role have I chosen to play, and what character does that role require?

What part of this discomfort is meaningful, and what part is unnecessary self-punishment?

Who or what am I stewarding that makes this pain worth carrying?

What is the next concrete action that would make me more useful?

These questions move you away from shame and toward practice. Practice is the art of becoming. Shame keeps us small.

These questions help you turn a vague identity threat into a specific development path.

Confidence Is Not the Starting Point

Waiting to feel ready is often a trap.

In high-responsibility environments, confidence usually comes after action, not before it. You act, learn, adjust, and act again. Over time, your identity catches up with your responsibility.

This is why values matter.

Values give you a way to move before certainty arrives.

You may not feel fully confident, but you can act with integrity.

You may not feel fully ready, but you can act with discipline.

You may not feel fully certain, but you can act with care.

You may not feel like you belong yet, but you can serve the work in front of you.

That is stewardship.

The Bottom Line

Imposter syndrome is not always something to eliminate.

Sometimes it is the ache of becoming.

It shows up when the role is bigger than the identity you have been living from. It presses on the gap between who you have been and who the work is asking you to become.

The objective is not to suffer for the sake of suffering.

The objective is to carry meaningful pressure in service of meaningful evolution.

When imposter syndrome is interpreted through ego, it becomes shame.

When it is interpreted through values, it becomes maturity.

When it is interpreted through stewardship, it becomes a call:

That is not fraudulence.

That is transformation.

–––––

Adam Kreek and his team are on a mission to positively impact organizational cultures and leaders who make things happen.

He authored the bestselling business book, The Responsibility Ethic: 12 Strategies Exceptional People Use to Do the Work and Make Success Happen. 

Want to increase your leadership achievement? Learn more about Kreek’s coaching here.

Want to book a keynote that leaves a lasting impact? Learn more about Kreek’s live event service here.