
"When someone gives you feedback, assume positive intent."
Indra Nooyi
Former chair and CEO of PepsiCo
- Date
Six Questions for a Better Management Review
posted in Leadership

Adam Kreek
An operations leader once told me he would get partway through a report, realise he was still trying to work out why some random detail mattered, and go back to the top. Why did his report share this with him? How did this apply to the bigger picture?
He wanted to know what had changed since the last review and where his attention would help. The report he was given, did not help him do his job. Instead, the report made him do more detective work.
I heard a different version of the same frustration from a leader who already had a team scoreboard, clear project reporting and a regular meeting cadence. They were an expert in execution management. Managers could explain the latest results. Then they had to pull a plan out of each update. They wanted their managers to exercise their own judgement, yet the leader could feel themself getting impatient and destroying morale, agency and autonomy. They declined into telling their reports exactly what to do and how to do it.
Another executive was tired of being the person who carried information between capable colleagues. By the time one team heard what another was doing, the chance to shape the work had often passed. Her instinct was to give the meeting she already had a clearer job. Put commitments and dates on the standing agenda, and say which items were for awareness and which needed input while there was still time to act.
I like to use six questions to guide leaders to make that shift. The scorecard, the written update and the meeting all have a part to play. Together they should tell you where to pay attention, what the team will do and which decisions it needs from you.
Six questions for your next management review
1. Overview
What changed during this period, and why does it matter?
Start with the last outlook. What happened as expected? What changed enough to affect a priority, a customer or another team? Give steady work a short on-track line. Put the detail where people can find it if they need it.
2. Wins and Gaps
What went well, where did we fall short, and what helped or held us back?
Pull up the actions you committed to last time. Which did you finish? Which slipped? Give the team credit for what worked and be specific about what got in its way. A shortfall can come from the way the work was set up, a decision that arrived late or an expectation people understood differently. Each calls for a different response.
3. Learning and Changes
What surprised us, what are we learning, and what might we do differently?
Ask the people closest to the work what they learned and what they would try next. If a missed handoff keeps coming up, get curious about when the next team actually receives the information. The change might be as small as making the handoff two days earlier and seeing what happens.
4. Outlook
What do we expect in the next reporting period?
Name the result you currently expect and the assumption it depends on. A simple forecast helps peers plan their own work. Agree on which developments warrant an early call, especially if another team would have to change its plans before the next review.
5. Key Actions
What will we do next, who will lead it and by when?
Give each commitment an owner, a due date and a result the team can recognise when it sees it. Ask the people receiving a handoff to confirm it in the room. Bring these same commitments back to the next review. For larger changes, use milestones that make progress visible across teams.
6. Decisions, Resources and Support Required
What do we need from others, why, and by when?
Name the person who can help, what you need from them and what the timing changes. One leader recalled asking a team what was keeping it from meeting the standard. The team was waiting for a routine equipment approval. Once he knew that, he had a specific decision he could make. Give the people in your review that same chance to help.
One variation for teams with a scoreboard
The leader who was tired of extracting a plan wanted managers to begin with what they understood was expected of them. I like that move. Before showing the actuals, write down the result you believed you had agreed to deliver. If the manager and the leader name different targets, they have something to sort out before judging the result.
Then look forward. What is expected now, what will be expected by the next review and what does the manager propose to do about it? Ask each person to connect their numbers to the result the team shares. That gives peers a reason to ask questions, offer help and flag a trade-off before it reaches the boss.
Try it in the meeting you already have
Choose one shared priority. Ask each lead, including the senior leader, to give short written answers to all six questions ahead of the meeting. When you meet, spend your time on what moved, where teams need one another and which decisions have a deadline. Close by reading back who is doing what and by when. If you are deciding where the review belongs, start with your existing meeting cadence.
At the next review, put the previous outlook and commitments on the table. You will have something concrete to learn from, and the team will see what became of the help it asked for.
If your leadership team is working through this, I help teams build a planning and review rhythm they can use between offsites.
Adam Kreek, Values Driven Achievement
Quote source Indra Nooyi’s farewell letter to PepsiCo associates.
Portrait Remy Steinegger / World Economic Forum, CC BY-SA 2.0. Cropped and finished in Canva Slate.